The Difference I Noticed Between Natural and Induced Contractions
The Difference I Noticed Between Natural and Induced Contractions
Disclosure: Throughout this post, you may find affiliate links to products or resources I personally use and love. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I'm also an Earthley affiliate and may earn commissions on some links shared - always at no extra cost to you.
There’s a big difference between reading about contractions… and actually feeling them. And after experiencing both an induction (with Cytotec and a Foley bulb) and then a completely natural, unmedicated birth later on, I can say this with 100% confidence: Natural contractions feel totally different than induced contractions. Not just in intensity — but in how your body can work with them.
If you’ve only experienced an induction, you might think, “There’s no way contractions can be less painful than that.” But honestly? My natural contractions were a completely different experience — more controlled, more intuitive, and so much easier to cope with. And if you want a deeper breakdown of birth prep, trauma healing, and mindset support, make sure you’re on my Birth Series Interest List — I have 8 trauma-aware birth workbooks coming soon.
1. “Are induced contractions actually more painful?” — What my midwife told me
Before my second birth, I asked my midwife the common question: “Are induced contractions really more painful than natural ones?” She gave me the most helpful explanation that stuck with me the entire pregnancy. She said: “A lot of it is about anticipation. If I tell you I’m going to push you off a bike, you’re going to tense up and think about it the whole time. But if you fall off a bike by yourself, you weren’t bracing for it — you just reacted naturally.” That made so much sense to me, especially as I reflected on my contractions during my first birth when I was induced. Induction doesn’t just affect your body — it affects your mind, your nervous system, and your ability to flow with the sensations. Studies show that induced contractions tend to be stronger, more intense, and more painful because medications like misoprostol or Pitocin stimulate the uterus differently than your natural hormonal rhythms¹. Natural oxytocin creates more rhythmic, wave-like contractions, while synthetic methods can create sharper or more frequent ones. And that was exactly what I felt.
2. My induction: Cytotec + Foley bulb = overwhelming, fast, and chaotic
When my induction started at 39 weeks, my body wasn’t ready at all.
I wasn’t dilated.
I wasn’t effaced.
I wasn’t contracting.
Nothing was happening.
So everything that followed was completely forced on mine and my baby’s body when we weren’t prepared.
→ First round of Cytotec: mild but noticeable.
→ Second round: contractions got intense fast.
No build-up.
No warm-up.
Just sudden discomfort that kept climbing.
And then…
→ The Foley bulb.
This was honestly the most painful part of the entire induction — even without active labor. I had zero medication at this point, and the Foley bulb hit me like a freight train. My body wasn’t doing any of this naturally, and instead of easing into contractions, my system felt hijacked. Because my body wasn’t leading the process, I couldn’t connect with what was happening. I couldn’t anticipate when a contraction was starting or ending. I couldn’t get into a rhythm. The pain felt chaotic, sharp, and unpredictable — and it eventually pushed me into choosing an epidural.
If you want the full breakdown of these experiences, I go way deeper here:
• Truth About Cytotec for Labor Induction
• Foley Bulb for Labor: Pros, Cons & What It Felt Like
3. Why induced contractions felt harder for me
Here are the biggest differences I noticed — and what research has shown too:
• They start stronger and escalate faster. There’s no gradual warm-up. It’s very “zero to sixty,” because medications artificially stimulate the uterus in a way your natural hormone flow doesn’t.
• There’s no built-in hormonal support. Natural birth involves oxytocin, beta-endorphins, and your body’s own “pain management” system. Synthetic induction bypasses that rhythm².
• Your body isn’t always ready. I was not dilated or effaced. That alone intensifies pain because your tissues aren’t softened or primed yet.
• You lose the mind-body rhythm. This was the biggest thing for me. With induction, my body was reacting — not leading. I felt disconnected, like I couldn’t catch up.
• There’s more tension and anticipation. My midwife’s bike analogy was spot-on. I was bracing the entire time.
4. My natural, unmedicated birth: completely different sensations
When I went into labor naturally, I finally understood what people meant when they say contractions feel like “waves.”
• I could predict each contraction. I could feel it building…
Rising…
Peaking…
And then fading.
My breath synced with the rhythm.
My body responded instead of panicking.
• The pain had purpose.
Instead of sharp chaos, it felt like pressure and intensity that I could work with.
• I wasn’t afraid. I knew what my body was doing. I could move through each wave instead of gripping against it.
• I could relax my bottom and pelvic floor.
Thank you, Ina May’s Guide to Childbirth — seriously. That book changed how I understood my body, my anatomy, and why relaxing is so important³.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
• I stayed connected to myself.
This is the part I didn’t expect.
Natural contractions kept me present — fully in tune with my body’s pace, timing, and instincts.
If you want to see what physiological labor looks like step-by-step, these posts go into that further:
• What Does a Natural Birth Actually Look Like?
• How I Prepped My Body and Mind for a Natural Birth
5. Why natural contractions felt “easier” for me (even though they were intense)
Here’s the honest truth:
Natural contractions weren’t less intense — they were more manageable.
Because…
✓ My hormones were regulating the pain naturally.
✓ I wasn’t fighting my body.
✓ I could move freely.
✓ I wasn’t being monitored or interrupted constantly.
✓ I trusted what my body was doing.
✓ I wasn’t bracing in fear.
There is a very real body–mind connection in labor. Induction took me offline mentally.
Natural labor plugged me back in. If you’re processing an induction or preparing for a natural birth, please hear this: Your experience matters — and your body is capable of something different next time.
If you want support, guidance, and trauma-aware prep:
🤎 Join the Birth Series Interest List
🤎 Want a little heads-up when I post something New? Join my email list for updates, freebies, and honest mom-to-mom encouragement.
Want even more support for motherhood + wellness?
My Free Resources Page is full of checklists, swaps, and mom-friendly guides.
And you can always shop my favorite finds here:
Come Hang Out With Me on Socials:
TikTok:@the.nurture.nook
Instagram:@thenurture.nook
YouTube:@atthenurturenook
Pinterest:@atthenurturenook
Citations
¹ González González, N. L., et al. (2014). Induction of labor and women’s experience of childbirth. Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic & Neonatal Nursing, 43(1), 13–26.
² Buckley, S. (2015). Hormonal physiology of childbearing. Childbirth Connection.
³ Gaskin, I. M. (2003). Ina May’s Guide to Childbirth. Bantam Books.
